id int64 | image image | image_content list | question_type string | question string | gt_answer string | gemma3-4b_answer string | judge_explanation string | hallucination_score int64 | hallucination bool |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0 | [
"Fire hydrant"
] | attribute | What color is the fire hydrant cap in the picture? | The color of the fire hydrant cap in the image is yellow. | The fire hydrant cap is yellow and red. | Explanation: The model claims the fire hydrant cap is both yellow and red, but the ground-truth answer and image content indicate only yellow. The addition of red is unsupported.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
1 | [
"Door",
"Building"
] | adversarial | Who is sitting on the bench? | No one is sitting on the bench. | A person is sitting on the bench. | Explanation: The model's claim that a person is sitting on the bench contradicts the ground-truth answer and cannot be supported by the image content.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
2 | [
"Vase",
"Houseplant",
"Stool",
"Coffee table",
"Flower"
] | comparison | Which wooden stool has a vase with red flower on it? | The left wooden stool has a vase with a red flower on it. | The left stool holds the red flower. | Explanation: The model correctly identifies that the left stool holds the red flower, which aligns with the ground-truth answer and the image content.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
3 | [
"Traffic light",
"Building",
"House",
"Street light",
"Tree"
] | counting | How many traffic lights are there in the image? | There are four traffic lights in the image. | There are four traffic lights visible in the image. | Explanation: The model answer matches the ground-truth answer and is supported by the image content.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
4 | [
"Traffic sign",
"Traffic light",
"Building"
] | relation | What colors are the traffic signs at the top, in the middle, and at the bottom? | The traffic signs at the top and bottom are white, while the one in the center is blue. | Blue, red, and yellow respectively. | Explanation: The model's answer states the colors as blue, red, and yellow, which contradicts the ground-truth answer that specifies the top and bottom signs are white and the middle one is blue. This claim is not supported by the ground-truth or the image content.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
5 | [
"Wheel"
] | environment | How would you describe the weather in the image? | The photo was captured during nighttime, with a dark sky overhead. It depicts a Ferris wheel surrounded by people and illuminated by the lights. | Dark, illuminated, and festive night with lights. | Explanation: The model's description of the weather as "dark" and "illuminated" at night aligns with the image content and ground-truth answer. The term "festive" is an interpretation but not a false claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
6 | [
"Building",
"Street light",
"Tree",
"Traffic sign",
"Window"
] | holistic | Describe the image in detail. | The picture depicts a city street, recently dampened by rain, with a sidewalk lined by trees. There are several cars parked on the right, while others move along the road. A few pedestrians can be seen at a distance on the sidewalk, some of them holding umbrellas to protect themselves from the rain. The trees offer sha... | Rainy street scene with trees and buildings. | Explanation: The model answer is a brief but accurate summary of the image content and question without adding unsupported details.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
7 | [
"Parking meter",
"Telephone"
] | other | How much is it per hour to park at the parking meter? | It is $4 per hour to park at the parking meter. | $4.00 per hour, Monday through Saturday. | Explanation: The model's answer states "$4.00 per hour, Monday through Saturday," which adds the detail about the days of the week. The image and question do not provide information about specific days, and the ground-truth answer only states "$4 per hour" without mentioning days. Therefore, the claim about "Monday thr... | 1 | true | |
8 | [
"Car",
"Wheel",
"Land vehicle",
"Building"
] | attribute | What color are the two cars from right to left in the image? | The two cars from right to left in the image are black and blue. | Blue and grey, from left to right. | Explanation: The model's answer incorrectly states the colors as "blue and grey" and reverses the order, while the ground-truth answer specifies "black and blue" from right to left. This contradicts the ground-truth and is not supported by the image or question.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
9 | [
"Tire",
"Motorcycle",
"Wheel"
] | adversarial | What is the gender of the person riding the motorcycle in the image? | No one is riding the motorcycle by the roadside in the image. | Cannot determine the rider’s gender. | Explanation: The model correctly states that the rider’s gender cannot be determined, which aligns with the fact that no one is riding the motorcycle in the image.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
10 | [
"Wheel",
"Building",
"Truck",
"Person",
"Auto part"
] | comparison | In the image, which truck (left or right) has its door open? | The fire truck, which is on the left side of the image, has its door open. | The right truck has its door open. | Explanation: The model's claim that the right truck has its door open contradicts the ground-truth answer stating the left truck has its door open.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
11 | [
"Tree",
"Plant",
"Person",
"Land vehicle",
"Bicycle helmet",
"Sports equipment",
"Bicycle",
"Vehicle",
"Mammal",
"Bicycle wheel"
] | counting | How many bicycles are there in the image? | In the image, there are four bicycles: two at the front, one in the middle, and one in the distance. | There are three bicycles in the image. | Explanation: The ground-truth answer states there are four bicycles, but the model claims there are three, which contradicts the supported information.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
12 | [
"Person",
"Mammal",
"Boat"
] | relation | How is the yellow boat positioned in relation to the white yacht in the image? | The yellow boat is positioned in front of the white yacht in the image. | The yellow boat is to the right of yacht. | Explanation: The model answer states the yellow boat is to the right of the yacht, but the ground-truth answer and image indicate the yellow boat is in front of the white yacht. This is a false claim about the boat's position.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
13 | [
"Train",
"Skyscraper",
"Car",
"Land vehicle",
"Plant",
"Vehicle",
"Wheel",
"Tree"
] | environment | What is the weather like in the image? | In the image, the weather appears to be either sunny or cloudy. | Overcast and somewhat cloudy, with light rain. | Explanation: The model claims there is light rain and overcast weather, but the image content and ground-truth answer only support sunny or cloudy conditions, with no mention or indication of rain.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
14 | [
"Wheel",
"Bus",
"Person",
"Auto part",
"Land vehicle"
] | holistic | Describe the image in detail. | The picture presents a yellow school bus stationed on an urban roadway, alongside a bicyclist. Positioned outside a tattoo establishment, the bus offers a unique urban backdrop. The road is notably calm, with the absence of other vehicles and passersby. The cyclist, equipped with a backpack and helmet, seems to be a st... | Yellow school bus with a cyclist in NYC. | Explanation: The model answer correctly identifies a yellow school bus and a cyclist, which are visible in the image. However, the claim that the location is "NYC" is not supported or reasonably inferred from the image, question, or ground-truth answer.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
15 | [
"Person",
"Fixed-wing aircraft"
] | other | Which company owns the airplane displayed in the back of the image? | The airplane in the background of the image is owned by Virgin Airlines. | Virgin Atlantic owns the airplane in the image. | Explanation: The model's claim that Virgin Atlantic owns the airplane is supported by the ground-truth answer stating Virgin Airlines owns it. Virgin Atlantic is a part of Virgin Airlines, so this is a reasonable inference and not a hallucination.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
16 | [
"Plant",
"Tree",
"Man",
"Sports equipment",
"Human arm"
] | attribute | What are the colors of the shirts worn by the three men from left to right in the image? | The three men from left to right in the image are wearing green, blue, and red shirts. | Green, blue, and red shirts. | Explanation: The model answer correctly states the colors of the shirts as green, blue, and red, which matches the ground-truth answer and can be reasonably inferred from the image.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
17 | [
"Human head",
"Boy",
"Human ear",
"Human eye",
"Human mouth",
"Human face",
"Man",
"Human hair",
"Human body",
"Mammal",
"Human nose",
"Clothing"
] | adversarial | Which color are the glasses that the man in the image is wearing? | The man is not wearing glasses. | The glasses are black. | Explanation: The model claims the man is wearing black glasses, but the ground-truth answer states the man is not wearing glasses, and the image content does not support the presence of glasses.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
18 | [
"Clothing",
"Human body",
"Person",
"Man",
"Mammal"
] | comparison | Who in the picture is wearing trousers? | The woman in the image wears the pants. | The man is wearing trousers. | Explanation: The model's claim that the man is wearing trousers contradicts the ground-truth answer stating the woman is wearing the pants.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
19 | [
"Girl",
"Human head",
"Human hair",
"Mammal",
"Dog",
"Person",
"Human face"
] | counting | How many people are there in the image? | There are four people in the image. | There are five people in the image. | Explanation: The model answer states there are five people, but the ground-truth answer and the image content indicate there are four people.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
20 | [
"Mammal",
"Human nose",
"Human mouth",
"Human face",
"Clothing",
"Poster",
"Person",
"Human hair"
] | relation | Where is the girl positioned among the three people in the image? | The girl stands on the right among the three individuals in the image. | She is positioned to the right of Spider-Man. | Explanation: The model's answer specifies the girl's position relative to Spider-Man, which is not supported by the image content, question, or ground-truth answer. The ground-truth only states she is on the right among the three people, without mentioning Spider-Man.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
21 | [
"Human face",
"Fashion accessory",
"Human arm",
"Human hair",
"Human head",
"Human leg",
"Man",
"Human mouth",
"Sunglasses",
"Human body",
"Swimwear",
"Boy",
"Goggles"
] | environment | Is the man in the picture indoors or outdoors? | The man in the photo is outside, sitting on a boat with several oxygen tanks around him. | Outdoors, on a boat by the sea. | Explanation: The model's answer that the man is outdoors on a boat by the sea is consistent with the ground-truth answer stating he is outside on a boat with oxygen tanks. There is no unsupported or false claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
22 | [
"Window",
"Clothing",
"Person",
"Building"
] | holistic | Describe the image in detail. | The image captures a bustling street lined with various shops and an adjoining sidewalk. Several pedestrians are present, with two individuals notably passing a store with a green sign saying "Hawkin's Bazaar". At this store's entrance, a man stands, overseeing a spacious window display that houses diverse items, highl... | Hawkins Bazaar shop with festive, colorful window display. | Explanation: The model's answer correctly identifies the "Hawkins Bazaar" shop and mentions a festive, colorful window display, which can be reasonably inferred from the image and question. It does not make any unsupported claims beyond what is visible or stated.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
23 | [
"Person",
"Clothing",
"Sports equipment",
"Mammal",
"Footwear"
] | other | What number is the fastest girl wearing in the picture? | The fastest girl in the picture is wearing number 1097. | 11097 is the number she’s wearing. | Explanation: The model answer states the number as "11097," which is not supported by the ground-truth answer "1097" and is not visible in the image. This is a false claim about the number worn.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
24 | [
"Dog"
] | attribute | What are the colors of the dogs from right to left? | The colors of the two dogs from right to left are brown and black. | Gray and tan/golden brown. | Explanation: The model's answer does not match the ground-truth colors of the dogs, which are brown and black. The model claims gray and tan/golden brown, which is unsupported by the ground-truth.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
25 | [
"Animal",
"Bird"
] | adversarial | What is a vicuna standing in the sand looking at? | There is no vicuna in the image. | The toucan, not a vicuna. | Explanation: The model correctly identifies that there is no vicuna in the image and instead mentions a toucan, which is consistent with the image content showing a bird. There is no false or unsupported claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
26 | [
"Mammal",
"Cat"
] | comparison | Which cat (left, right or middle) in the image opens its mouth? | The cat on the right side of the image opens its mouth. | The middle cat is opening its mouth. | Explanation: The model's claim that the middle cat is opening its mouth contradicts the ground-truth answer and the visible image content, which shows the right cat opening its mouth.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
27 | [
"Zebra",
"Plant"
] | counting | How many zebras are there in the image? | There are six zebras in the image. | There are four zebras visible in the image. | Explanation: The model answer states there are four zebras, but the ground-truth answer and the image content indicate there are six zebras. This is a false claim about the number of zebras.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
28 | [
"Plant",
"Sheep",
"Tree"
] | relation | Which sheep is in front of the other sheep? | The sheep in front of the other sheep is a white sheep. | The grey sheep is in front. | Explanation: The image and ground-truth answer indicate the sheep in front is white, but the model claims the grey sheep is in front, which contradicts the provided information.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
29 | [
"Footwear",
"Sports equipment",
"Clothing",
"Person",
"Helmet",
"Animal",
"Man",
"Human leg",
"Human body"
] | environment | How was the weather when this picture was captured? | When this photo was taken, it was dark at night. This photo shows a horse race at night. | Dark, illuminated by stadium lights at night. | Explanation: The model's claim that it was dark and illuminated by stadium lights at night is supported by the ground-truth answer stating it was night and the image context of a horse race, which typically occurs in such settings.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
30 | [
"Zebra",
"Tree",
"Mammal",
"Giraffe",
"Plant"
] | holistic | Describe the image in detail. | The image depicts three zebras and four giraffes on a sandy terrain, with trees in the background and a stone structure to the right. Surrounding the scene is fencing, suggesting a controlled environment like a zoo or nature reserve. | Giraffes and zebras near a rocky, sandy enclosure. | Explanation: The model answer correctly identifies giraffes and zebras near a sandy enclosure, which aligns with the image content and ground-truth answer. It does not make any unsupported claims.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
31 | [
"Rhinoceros",
"Mammal"
] | other | Out of the four animals, how many giraffes are there in the image? | In the image, there are two rhinos, a giraffe, and a wild horse. | There are zero giraffes in the image. | Explanation: The ground-truth answer states there is one giraffe in the image, but the model answer claims there are zero giraffes, which contradicts the ground-truth.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
32 | [
"Fruit"
] | attribute | Is the kiwi in the front fresh or dried? | The kiwi in the front is dried. There are four dried pieces of kiwi in the front, and three fresh ones in the back. | The front kiwis appear fresh, not dried. | Explanation: The model's claim that the front kiwis appear fresh contradicts the ground-truth answer stating the front kiwis are dried.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
33 | [
"Dessert",
"Bread"
] | adversarial | Is the jam on the bread made of strawberry? | In fact, this photo only shows a cut and toasted bread slice. There is no jam on it. | It’s impossible to tell definitively from the image. | Explanation: The model correctly states that it is impossible to tell if the jam is strawberry since the image shows only toasted bread with no visible jam.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
34 | [
"Vegetable",
"Tomato",
"Food"
] | comparison | Compare the tomatoes in the photo. | There are three tomatoes from the same vine in the photo. The tomato on the left side is red and ripe, while the two tomatoes in the middle and on the right side are yellow and unripe. | They vary in size, color, and ripeness. | Explanation: The model's claim that the tomatoes vary in color and ripeness is supported by the ground-truth answer, which states one tomato is red and ripe, and the other two are yellow and unripe. The model also mentions size variation, which can be reasonably inferred from the image showing tomatoes of different siz... | 0 | false | |
35 | [
"Oyster",
"Food",
"Invertebrate",
"Animal",
"Seafood"
] | counting | How many oysters can you see in the photo? | There are five oysters visible in the photo. | I can see approximately eight oysters. | Explanation: The model claims there are approximately eight oysters, but the ground-truth answer states there are five oysters visible. This is a false claim about the quantity of oysters in the image.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
36 | [
"Dessert",
"Baked goods",
"Broccoli",
"Fast food",
"Cookie"
] | relation | Is the bowl with broccoli on top of the bowl with meatballs? | No, the bowl with broccoli is next to the bowl of meatballs. | Yes, broccoli sits on top of meatballs. | Explanation: The model incorrectly states that the bowl with broccoli is on top of the bowl with meatballs, while the ground-truth answer and image content indicate they are next to each other.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
37 | [
"Snack",
"Clothing",
"Mammal",
"Person",
"Human body",
"Human hand",
"Fast food",
"Food",
"Man",
"Human arm",
"Woman",
"Seafood"
] | environment | Is this photo taken in a restaurant, a kitchen, or anywhere else? | This photo is taken outdoors, likely on a beach, where a man is cooking on a grill. | Likely a barbeque or outdoor cooking event. | Explanation: The model answer states it is likely a barbeque or outdoor cooking event, which aligns with the ground-truth answer indicating the photo is taken outdoors where a man is cooking on a grill. There is no false or unsupported claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
38 | [
"Man",
"Food",
"Clothing",
"Vegetable"
] | holistic | Describe the activities in this image. | In this image we can see a man and two young girls preparing food. The man seems to be a chef with a suit but no hat. The two girls seem to be interns, wearing aprons with a "BRITANNIA HOTEL" logo. The man seems to be guiding the girls to prepare the food. In front of them, there is a table with food on it. From left t... | People are preparing food, likely for a meal. | Explanation: The model answer states that people are preparing food, which is supported by the image and question. It does not make any unsupported claims or add false information.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
39 | [
"Fast food",
"Clothing",
"Snack",
"Person",
"Food"
] | other | From this photo, how much does each jerk chicken dumpling cost? | Each jerk chicken dumpling costs 5 pounds. | £5.00 for each jerk chicken dumpling. | Explanation: The model answer states the price as £5.00 per jerk chicken dumpling, which matches the ground-truth answer of 5 pounds. There is no unsupported or false claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
40 | [
"Sports equipment",
"Parachute"
] | attribute | What are the colors of the parachutes in the sky? | There are three parachutes in the sky. The one on the left is light green. The one on the top right is orange. The one on the bottom right is blue. | Green, orange, and blue are visible colors. | Explanation: The model answer correctly identifies the colors green, orange, and blue, which aligns with the ground-truth answer and the image content. There are no false or unsupported claims.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
41 | [
"Tennis racket",
"Ball (Object)"
] | adversarial | Describe the person playing tennis in this photo. | No, there is only a tennis racket and a ball on the ground. No one is playing tennis in this photo. | A tennis player is focused on the game. | Explanation: The model claims there is a tennis player, but the image and ground-truth answer confirm there is no person playing tennis in the photo.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
42 | [
"Surfboard"
] | comparison | Compare the two surfboards in the photo. | The two surfboards have different looks. The surfboard on the top has a white and wood color with a simple design. The other one on the bottom is red, with a more complex white and black pattern in the front. | One is wooden, the other is brightly colored. | Explanation: The model's claim that one surfboard is wooden and the other is brightly colored is supported by the image and the ground-truth answer. There are no false or unsupported claims.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
43 | [
"Horse",
"Person",
"Mammal",
"Tree"
] | counting | How many horses are there in the photo? | There are three horses in the photo. | There are three horses in the photo. | Explanation: The model answer matches the ground-truth answer and is supported by the image content.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
44 | [
"Ball (Object)",
"Furniture",
"Billiard table",
"Table"
] | relation | What is the color of the ball on the left? | The color of the ball on the left is red or orange. | Orange. | Explanation: The model answer "Orange" is consistent with the ground-truth answer stating the ball on the left is red or orange, and it does not contradict the image content.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
45 | [
"Person",
"Mammal",
"Sports equipment",
"Footwear",
"Helmet",
"Clothing"
] | environment | Is this photo taken indoors or outdoors? | The photo is taken indoors, since there is a group of hockey players playing in an ice stadium. | It’s clearly taken indoors on an ice rink. | Explanation: The model answer correctly states the photo is taken indoors on an ice rink, which aligns with the ground-truth answer and the image content.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
46 | [
"Human arm",
"Footwear",
"Football",
"Clothing",
"Man",
"Mammal",
"Human body",
"Sports equipment",
"Human hand"
] | holistic | Describe the activity in this photo. | In this photo, three players are playing soccer. The first player on the left wears a white and red uniform, and is controlling the ball. The other two players on the right side are from the other team. They wear blue and yellow uniforms. The player closer to the camera is competing with the first player to gain contro... | Soccer players are actively playing a football match. | Explanation: The model answer correctly identifies that soccer players are playing a football match, which is supported by the image content and the question. It does not make any unsupported claims or add false information.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
47 | [
"Person",
"Footwear",
"Tennis racket",
"Sports equipment",
"Human arm",
"Ball (Object)"
] | other | Which tournament is this tennis competition? | From the text on the ground, this is the Indian Wells tournament. | It’s the Indian Wells Masters tournament. | Explanation: The model answer correctly identifies the tournament as the Indian Wells Masters, which aligns with the ground-truth answer stating it is the Indian Wells tournament. There is no unsupported or false claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
48 | [
"Home appliance",
"Cupboard",
"Cabinetry",
"Kitchen appliance",
"Countertop",
"Microwave oven",
"Furniture",
"Sink",
"Drawer",
"Refrigerator",
"House",
"Plumbing fixture"
] | attribute | What color is the microwave? | The microwave is mainly silver, with a black panel. | It appears to be stainless steel. | Explanation: The model's answer that the microwave "appears to be stainless steel" is consistent with the ground-truth answer stating it is mainly silver, which is a common description for stainless steel appliances. There is no false or unsupported claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
49 | [
"House",
"Cupboard",
"Kitchen & dining room table",
"Cabinetry",
"Home appliance",
"Table",
"Kitchen appliance",
"Chair",
"Window"
] | adversarial | How many people are eating in this kitchen? | No one is eating in the kitchen. I can see a dining table and four chairs, but there are no people in the sitting there right now. | It appears no one is eating there. | Explanation: The model answer states that no one is eating in the kitchen, which is supported by the image content and the ground-truth answer. There is no false or unsupported claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
50 | [
"Kitchen utensil",
"Fork",
"Spoon",
"Tableware",
"Toy",
"Person"
] | comparison | Compare the utensils in the picture. | The picture shows a set of three utensils in different views with a white background: A knive with a blue handle, a spoon with a yellow handle, and a red fork with a red handle. They are all made of metal and plastic handle. | Colorful, building-block shaped, and unique eating utensils. | Explanation: The model's answer describes the utensils as "colorful, building-block shaped, and unique eating utensils," which is consistent with the image content and the ground-truth answer that mentions different colored handles and the utensils being distinct. There is no false or unsupported claim in the model's a... | 0 | false | |
51 | [
"Kitchen utensil",
"Fork",
"Tableware",
"Tool"
] | counting | How many forks can you see? | There are two forks. | There are three visible forks in the image. | Explanation: The model claims there are three forks, but the ground-truth answer states there are two forks. The image content also supports only two forks being present.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
52 | [
"Coffee cup",
"Spoon",
"Mug",
"Tableware",
"Kitchen utensil"
] | relation | What are the objects from right to left? | The objects from right to left are a lid, a spoon, and a coffee cup. | Mug, saucer, spoon, coffee objects. | Explanation: The model answer incorrectly identifies a "mug" and "saucer" instead of a "lid" and does not clearly list the objects in the correct order from right to left as per the ground-truth answer. It also adds "coffee objects," which is vague and unsupported.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
53 | [
"Sink",
"Gas stove",
"Shelf",
"Furniture",
"Drawer",
"Home appliance",
"Cabinetry",
"Table",
"Cupboard",
"Countertop",
"House",
"Chair"
] | environment | At what time is this photo taken? | The photo is taken during the day. | Daylight, likely in the morning or afternoon. | Explanation: The model's answer that the photo is taken during daylight is supported by the ground-truth answer stating it is taken during the day. The additional inference of "likely in the morning or afternoon" is reasonable given daylight but not explicitly confirmed by the image or ground truth. However, this is a ... | 0 | false | |
54 | [
"Kitchen & dining room table",
"Window",
"Chair"
] | holistic | Describe this photo in detail. | This photo features a wooden dining table with four wooden or metal chairs around it. On the table there are two coasters and two glass cups. The table is set on a wooden floor. Behind the table are the wall and two windows. | Wooden table with chairs in a sunlit room. | Explanation: The model answer is a brief but accurate description of the image content without adding any unsupported details.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
55 | [
"Home appliance",
"Toaster",
"Oven",
"Furniture",
"Gas stove",
"Drawer",
"Cabinetry",
"Kitchen appliance"
] | other | In the picture, which buttons should I use to control the stove above? | There are 8 buttons in front of the stainless steel stove, two on the left and six on the right. Since there are also six stoves above, the buttons on the right should be associated with the stoves and used to control them. There is also a digital display to the left of the buttons that shows "5:27", which is possibly ... | The knobs control the burners. | Explanation: The model answer claims "The knobs control the burners," but the image and ground-truth answer mention buttons, not knobs, and specify that the buttons on the right control the stove. The model's claim about knobs is unsupported and contradicts the provided information.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
56 | [
"Umbrella",
"Fashion accessory"
] | attribute | What color is the umbrella? | The umbrella is colorful, containing purple, yellow, teal, and orange. | It’s a rainbow of vibrant colors. | Explanation: The model's claim that the umbrella is "a rainbow of vibrant colors" is a reasonable inference from the ground-truth answer stating the umbrella contains multiple colors (purple, yellow, teal, and orange). There is no false or unsupported claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
57 | [
"Glove",
"Clothing",
"Fashion accessory"
] | adversarial | Describe the hands wearing the gloves. | Only a pair of black gloves can be observed in the image. There are no hands shown in the image. | Black hands in gloves, making a peace sign. | Explanation: The image and ground-truth answer indicate that only gloves are visible, with no hands shown. The model's claim of "black hands" is unsupported and false.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
58 | [
"Hiking equipment",
"Clothing",
"Backpack"
] | comparison | Compare the two different views of the backpack. | The image shows two different views of the same black backpack. On the left side, it shows the inside of the bag, containing a camera, two lenses an other accessories. On the right side, it shows the outside of the bag, and there is a "Lowepro" logo on it. | One open, one closed, for camera equipment. | Explanation: The model answer correctly states that one view is open and the other is closed, and that the backpack is for camera equipment, which is supported by the image and ground-truth. There are no false or unsupported claims.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
59 | [
"Clothing",
"Hat"
] | counting | How many black hats are there in the image? | There are five black hats in the image. | There are five black hats in the image. | Explanation: The model answer matches the ground-truth answer and is supported by the image content.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
60 | [
"Watch"
] | relation | Describe how the two watches are placed. | There are two watches side by side in the photo. The black one is placed on top of and to the left of the red one. | Stacked closely, one on top of the other. | Explanation: The model answer states the watches are stacked one on top of the other, which aligns with the ground-truth answer indicating the black watch is on top of the red one. The model does not mention the left placement, but this omission is not a hallucination.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
61 | [
"Footwear",
"Clothing"
] | environment | Is this photo taken indoors or outdoors? | This photo shows a pair of green training shoes on a carpet, so this photo is taken indoors. | Likely indoors, on a rug or carpet. | Explanation: The model answer states "Likely indoors, on a rug or carpet," which is consistent with the ground-truth answer and the image content showing shoes on a carpet. There is no false or unsupported claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
62 | [
"Man",
"Person",
"Clothing",
"Human hand",
"Human arm",
"Fashion accessory",
"Woman",
"Human body"
] | holistic | Describe the details in this photo. | In the photo, a woman's hand is holding a man's hand. The woman's hand is wearing a diamond wedding ring, while the man's hand is wearing a simple wedding band. It seems that the woman is in a white dress and the man is in a black suit, but only a part can be seen in this photo. The image is black and white, except the... | Hands holding wedding rings, symbolizing a commitment. | Explanation: The model's answer is vague but does not make any false or unsupported claims. It mentions "hands holding wedding rings," which aligns with the image and ground-truth description. The phrase "symbolizing a commitment" is a reasonable inference from the context of wedding rings. There is no specific incorre... | 0 | false | |
63 | [
"Cowboy hat",
"Man",
"Human face",
"Clothing",
"Human nose",
"Fedora",
"Human head",
"Glasses",
"Beard",
"Goggles",
"Human mouth",
"Human body",
"Mammal",
"Sunglasses",
"Human hair"
] | other | What can you see in the reflection from the sunglasses? | A man wearing a top hat and a suit is wearing this pair of sunglasses. From the reflection in his sunglasses, I can vaguely see some people, but not the man himself. | A distorted reflection of the person’s face. | Explanation: The model claims the reflection shows a distorted face, but the ground-truth answer states the reflection shows some people vaguely, not the man himself. The model's claim about the reflection content is not supported by the ground-truth or the image description.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
64 | [
"Table"
] | attribute | What is the color of the laptop? | The color of the laptop is silver (or white). A black color sticker is on the laptop. | The laptop is white. | Explanation: The model answer states the laptop is white, which is supported by the ground-truth answer indicating the laptop is silver (or white). There is no false or unsupported claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
65 | [
"Computer mouse"
] | adversarial | What is playing on the monitor? | There is no monitor in the image. | A white Apple mouse is visible. | Explanation: The model answer correctly states the presence of a white Apple mouse and does not claim anything about a monitor or what is playing on it. It does not hallucinate any unsupported information.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
66 | [
"Ipod",
"Mobile phone",
"Human hand",
"Telephone"
] | comparison | Which electronic device is larger? | The iPod touch on the left is larger than the iPod nano on the right. | The iPhone is noticeably larger than the iPod. | Explanation: The image shows an iPod and a mobile phone, but the ground-truth answer specifies the comparison is between an iPod touch and an iPod nano. The model's claim that the iPhone is larger than the iPod is unsupported by the image or question, and it introduces a device (iPhone) not mentioned in the ground-trut... | 1 | true | |
67 | [
"Person",
"Telephone",
"Human hand",
"Mobile phone"
] | counting | How many mobile phones are there in the image? | There is one mobile phone in the image. | There is one mobile phone in the image. | Explanation: The model answer correctly states the number of mobile phones visible in the image, which matches the ground-truth answer and is supported by the image content.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
68 | [
"Computer mouse"
] | relation | Is the mouse connected to a computer? | No, the mouse is not connected to a computer. | Yes, it’s connected via a USB. | Explanation: The image shows a computer mouse, but there is no visible cable or connection to a computer. The ground-truth answer states it is not connected, so the model's claim that it is connected via USB is unsupported and false.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
69 | [
"Mule"
] | environment | Where was the photo taken? | The photo was taken outside with plants and mountains as surroundings. | Likely a rural, outdoor setting, perhaps a field. | Explanation: The model answer reasonably infers an outdoor, rural setting based on the presence of a mule, which aligns with the ground-truth answer's mention of plants and mountains. There is no false or unsupported claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
70 | [
"Television",
"Person"
] | holistic | Describe the image in detail. | In this image, I see a book, a pen, and a television on a table. The TV screen shows a man wearing a tie and a suit speaking in a park. | Television displays a man, date, and landscape scene. | Explanation: The model answer mentions a "date" on the television display, which is not supported by the image content or the ground-truth answer. The ground-truth answer describes a man in a suit speaking in a park, but there is no mention or visible indication of a date on the TV screen.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: ... | 1 | true | |
71 | [
"Laptop",
"Computer keyboard"
] | other | Is this a Macbook or Windows laptop? | This is a Macbook, as indicated by the presence of the Apple logo on the keyboard. | It’s a Windows laptop, clearly. | Explanation: The model answer contradicts the ground-truth answer and the image indication of an Apple logo, falsely claiming it is a Windows laptop.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
72 | [
"Sofa bed",
"Loveseat",
"Studio couch",
"Bed",
"Pillow"
] | attribute | What are the colors of the pillows from left to right? | The colors of the pillows from left to right are white (or grey), yellow, and white (or grey). | Striped, yellow, and striped again. | Explanation: The model claims the pillows are striped and yellow, but the image and ground-truth indicate the pillows are white (or grey), yellow, and white (or grey). The model's description of "striped" pillows is unsupported.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
73 | [
"Window",
"House",
"Sofa bed",
"Studio couch",
"Bed"
] | adversarial | What is the color of the chair in the image? | There is no chair in the image. | The chair is a light, yellowish-brown color. | Explanation: The model claims there is a chair and describes its color, but the image content and ground-truth answer state there is no chair in the image.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
74 | [
"Pillow",
"Bed",
"Furniture",
"House",
"Building"
] | comparison | Which pillow is closer to the camera? | The pillow on the right side of the bed is closer to the camera. | The right pillow is closer to the camera. | Explanation: The model's answer directly matches the ground-truth answer and is supported by the image content.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
75 | [
"Coffee table",
"Furniture",
"Sofa bed",
"Table",
"Chair",
"House",
"Sports equipment",
"Window",
"Billiard table"
] | counting | How many chairs are there in the image? | There are two chairs in the image. | Three chairs are visible in the image. | Explanation: The model claims there are three chairs, but the ground-truth answer states there are two chairs. The image content list includes "Chair" but does not specify the number, so the ground-truth answer is the reliable source. The model's claim contradicts the ground-truth answer.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
76 | [
"Pillow",
"Human arm",
"Human body"
] | relation | Which pillow is in front of the other pillows? | There are three pillows. The gray pillow in the middle with the red "paper" handprint pattern is in front of the other pillows. The other two pillows are white and have a red "scissors" handprint pattern and a "stone" handprint pattern, respectively. | The gray pillow is in front. | Explanation: The model's answer correctly identifies the gray pillow as the one in front, which is supported by the ground-truth answer and the image content.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
77 | [
"Table",
"Furniture",
"Chair",
"Couch",
"House",
"Kitchen & dining room table",
"Fireplace"
] | environment | What was the weather like when this photo was taken? | When this photo was taken, it was already night and the sky was dark. | Dark, warm, and likely indoors. | Explanation: The model correctly infers that it is dark (night) from the image and question context, but the claim "warm" is not supported by any visible evidence in the image or question. The model also reasonably infers "indoors" from the furniture and fireplace, which is supported. However, the unsupported claim "wa... | 1 | true | |
78 | [
"Bed"
] | holistic | Describe the image in detail. | In this image we can see two deck beds with pillows on them and carpet on the floor. The Beds are mainly in the blue color and the pillows are yellow with blue strips. | Four bunk beds with yellow patterned bedding. | Explanation: The image shows two bunk beds, not four. The model's claim of "four bunk beds" is unsupported and incorrect. The description of bedding as "yellow patterned" is partially supported by the pillows but does not fully match the ground-truth detail about blue beds and yellow pillows with blue stripes. The main... | 1 | true | |
79 | [
"Bathroom cabinet",
"Toilet paper",
"Bathroom accessory",
"Door",
"Toilet"
] | other | Is the toilet paper used? | The toilet paper has not been used because it was folded into a decorative shape. | Yes, the toilet paper is not used. | Explanation: The model answer contradicts itself by saying "Yes" (implying it is used) and then stating "the toilet paper is not used." The ground-truth answer clearly states the toilet paper has not been used because it is folded decoratively. The model's claim that it is used is unsupported and false.
Hallucination: ... | 1 | true | |
80 | [
"Book"
] | attribute | What color are these books? | These books are red and white. | Red and black, with some gold accents. | Explanation: The model claims the books are red and black with gold accents, but the ground-truth answer states the books are red and white. The image content is not described in detail, but since the ground-truth answer contradicts the model's claim about the color black and gold accents, the model's answer contains h... | 1 | true | |
81 | [
"Tableware",
"Bowl",
"Vase",
"Flowerpot"
] | adversarial | What is in the vase? | Nothing is in the vase. | Nothing, it’s just an empty vase. | Explanation: The model answer states the vase is empty, which is supported by the image content and ground-truth answer.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
82 | [
"Vase"
] | comparison | Which vase looks larger? | The vase on the right appears larger. Both vases are white with blue and red flowers delicately painted on them. | The vase on the left appears larger. | Explanation: The model's claim that the vase on the left appears larger contradicts the ground-truth answer and the visible image content, which shows the vase on the right as larger.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
83 | [
"Tree",
"Teddy bear",
"Plant",
"Mammal",
"Christmas tree"
] | counting | How many teddy bears are on the stairs? | There are six teddy bears on the stairs. | There are seven teddy bears on the stairs. | Explanation: The model's claim of seven teddy bears contradicts the ground-truth answer of six teddy bears on the stairs.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
84 | [
"Flower",
"Houseplant",
"Flowerpot",
"Table",
"Building"
] | relation | Which color flowers are on top, and which color flowers are on the bottom? | The blue flowers are on top, and the white flowers are on the bottom. | Blue on top, white on bottom. | Explanation: The model answer correctly states the colors of the flowers on top and bottom as per the ground-truth answer.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
85 | [
"Person",
"Chair",
"Window",
"Clothing",
"Table",
"Building",
"House",
"Furniture"
] | environment | What was the weather like when this photo was taken? | When this photo was taken, it was already night and the sky was dark. | Dark and likely indoors, dimly lit. | Explanation: The model's answer that it was "dark and likely indoors, dimly lit" is consistent with the image content and the ground-truth answer stating it was night and the sky was dark. There is no false or unsupported claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
86 | [
"Human arm",
"Human body",
"Infant bed",
"Human leg",
"Person",
"Human nose",
"Clothing",
"Furniture",
"Human ear",
"Human eye",
"Human face",
"Human mouth",
"Human head",
"Boy",
"Human hair",
"Animal",
"Mammal",
"Teddy bear"
] | holistic | Describe the image in detail. | The image features a baby lying in a crib, which is placed in a room with a white background. The baby is wearing a diaper and is sleeping soundly. There are three stuffed animals hanging above the crib, providing a cozy and comforting atmosphere for the baby. | Newborn sleeping peacefully with plush animal toys. | Explanation: The model answer correctly identifies a sleeping baby and the presence of plush animal toys, which aligns with the image content and ground-truth answer. It does not include any false or unsupported claims.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
87 | [
"Book"
] | other | What is the name of the book? | The name of the book is "Proverbial Philosophy." | Proverbial Philosophy. | Explanation: The model answer correctly states the name of the book as "Proverbial Philosophy," which matches the ground-truth answer and is supported by the image content.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
88 | [
"Fruit"
] | attribute | What is the color of the pot? | The color of the pot is silver, with red cherries inside. | The pot is a shiny silver color. | Explanation: The model's claim that the pot is shiny silver is supported by the ground-truth answer stating the pot is silver. No unsupported claims are made.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
89 | [
"Bathroom accessory",
"Personal care",
"Sink",
"Tap"
] | adversarial | What is being washed in the sink? | Nothing is being washed in the sink. | Listerine mouthwash is being washed in the sink. | Explanation: The image and ground-truth answer indicate that nothing is being washed in the sink, so the claim that Listerine mouthwash is being washed is unsupported and false.
Hallucination: Yes → Rating: 1 | 1 | true | |
90 | [
"Kitchen appliance",
"Washing machine",
"Refrigerator"
] | comparison | Which washing machine is taller? | The right washing machine with the top load design is taller. Both are white in color. | The right washing machine is taller. | Explanation: The model answer correctly states that the right washing machine is taller, which is supported by the ground-truth answer and the image content.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
91 | [
"Turkey",
"Bird",
"Animal",
"Baked goods"
] | counting | How many chickens are cooked? | There is one cooked chicken in the image. | One whole, cooked turkey is present. | Explanation: The model answer incorrectly states that the cooked bird is a turkey, while the ground-truth answer specifies it is a cooked chicken. The image content includes both "Turkey" and "Bird," but the ground-truth clarifies the cooked bird is a chicken, not a turkey. Therefore, the model's claim is unsupported a... | 1 | true | |
92 | [
"Toilet paper",
"Bathroom accessory"
] | relation | What is placed on the tissue paper roll? | A screwdriver is placed on the tissue paper roll. | A roll of toilet paper. | Explanation: The model answer states "A roll of toilet paper," which is true but does not address what is placed on the tissue paper roll. The ground-truth answer specifies that a screwdriver is placed on the tissue paper roll. The model answer omits this detail but does not make any false claims. Therefore, there is n... | 0 | false | |
93 | [
"Countertop",
"Tap",
"Kitchen appliance",
"Window",
"Oven",
"House",
"Microwave oven",
"Cabinetry",
"Home appliance",
"Plumbing fixture",
"Sink"
] | environment | What time was the photo taken? | The photo was taken at daytime. | It’s difficult to determine the exact time. | Explanation: The model correctly states that the exact time cannot be determined, which is supported by the image and question. There is no false or unsupported claim.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
94 | [
"Food"
] | holistic | Describe the image in detail. | In this image, I can see food items (likely Baozi or buns) on papers and a tong kept on a metal stand in an oven and I can see steam on the glass. There are nine of them, arranged into a 3 x 3 grid. | Steamed buns sit inside a stainless steel case. | Explanation: The model's answer correctly identifies the steamed buns inside a stainless steel case, which aligns with the image content. It does not make any unsupported claims.
Hallucination: No → Rating: 0 | 0 | false | |
95 | [
"Bathroom accessory",
"Washing machine",
"Drawer",
"Furniture",
"Bathroom cabinet",
"Cabinetry",
"Sink",
"Plumbing fixture"
] | other | What is shown in the mirror? | The mirrow shows the reflection of the washing machine. | A reflection of the laundry room. | Explanation: The model answer states "a reflection of the laundry room," which is a broader claim than the ground-truth answer that specifies the reflection is of the washing machine. Since the washing machine is part of the laundry room, the model's answer is a reasonable inference and not a false claim.
Hallucination... | 0 | false |
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 29